Essay on Internet Privacy - Carnivore, and the Power Of FBI Surveillanc

Carnivore The Power Of FBI Surveillance Abstract This paper provides an analysis of the screen issues associated with political Internet surveillance, with a focus on the recently disclosed FBI tool known as Carnivore. It concludes that, while some system of surveillance is necessary, more mechanisms to proscribe abuse of privacy must exist. Communication surveillance has been a controversial issue in the US since the 1920s, when the Supreme Court deemed unwarranted wiretaps legitimate in the case of Olmstead v United States. Since telephone wires ran over public grounds, and the property of Olmstead was not physically violated, the wiretap was upheld as lawful. However, the Supreme Court overturned this opinion in 1967 in the landmark case of Katz v United States. On the basis of the fourth amendment, the court established that individuals have the right to privacy of communication, and that wiretapping is unconstitutional unless it is authorized by a search warrant. Bowyer, 1 42-143 Since then, the right to communication privacy has become accepted as an integral facet of the American deontological code of ethics. The FBI has make an at least perfunctory effort to respect the publics demand for Internet privacy with its new Internet surveillance system, Carnivore. However, the current implementation of Carnivore unnecessarily jeopardizes the privacy of innocent individuals. There is considerable utilitarian value in extending privacy rights to the Internet. The fear that communication is being monitored by a third party needfully leads to inefficiency, because individuals feel a need to find loopholes in the surveillance. For instance, if the public does not feel comfortable with communica... ... best way to establish this balance of power is by requiring the FBI to have the ISPs perform the searches themselves. Works Cited Kevin W. Bowyer. Ethics And Computing. IEEE Press, New York. 2001. (142-143). Patrick Ross. News.com. http//news.cnet.com/new s/0-1005-200-2713029.html September 2000 Patrick Riley. Fox News. http//www.foxnews.com/national/071100/carnivore.sml July 11th, 2000 Donald M. Kerr. FBI. http//www.fbi.gov/pressrm/congress/congress00/kerr090600.htm September 6th, 2000 IITRI. http//www.usdoj.gov/jmd/publications/carnivore_draft_1.pdf November 17th, 2000. Thomas C. Greene. The Register http//www.theregister.co.uk/ means/6/15591.html December 19th, 2000 Chris Oakes. Wired News. http//www.wired.com/news/politics/0,1283,37470,00.html July 12th, 2000